I haven’t written about email subject lines in a while but now I want to make it a regular Saturday feature on this blog.

I subscribe to very few email lists in my regular email inboxes because receiving too much email is distracting for me as an email copywriter.

But I have a dormant Yahoo mail account that I don’t use anymore because a lot of crud piles up there.

So I thought I’d go through some if it each Saturday and find the five subject lines that manage to get my attention in all that mess.

Here goes:

1. Cool Hues in Ocean Blues. The Sundance catalog sent this email. The subject line appealed to me because it rhymes and evokes a nice image.

2. Last Chance For Free Shipping, Hurry Ends Tonight. This is another Sundance subject line. It’s a good reminder that a straight-to-the-point subject line always works. Especially if the word “free” is in it.

3. Tips For Getting a Good Flight’s Sleep. This subject line is by Magellan’s travel catalog. I thought it was catchy and stood out from the crowd in my inbox.

4. Why You’re Unique, Special and Great. This subject line is by Mike Litman. Yeah, it’s kind of gimmicky. But it managed to catch my eye in the sea of crud in my inbox. Using the word “you” in a subject line is effective.

5. Capture brilliant ideas with our notebooks and journals. This is by one of my favorite catalogs – Levenger. First, I like that the only use a capital letter at the beginning of the subject line. This looks more natural, less sales-y.

Also, I like that they assume that my ideas are brilliant. And I’ve always had a fondness for notebooks.

See you next Saturday with more subject lines.

VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
Share

My favorite catalog, J. Peterman, is famous for their catalog copy and justifiably so. It’s lifestyle copy at its finest. Whenever an issue arrives I block out time that same day to sit on the couch and read it cover to cover.

Today I’m going to focus on their email copy instead. Their “Up to 63% off everything Beer-esque” was the best email subject line of the week to hit my inbox.

I like that they used a specific percentage – 63% – instead of something more normal, like 50%. In looking over their subject lines for the past year, I see they’ve used the following percentages: 81, 41, 47, 46, 52, 79.

I also like this subject line from last November: “10 items under $71.” They are running a 59% off sale on their website right now (these model roadsters are tempting, are they not?). So J. Peterman likes using those odd numbers and obviously those numbers work for them, so take note.

I’m not a beer drinker but even though this HTML email had pictures of beer and steins I clicked on it anyway, in the desperate hope that their Cortina Turtleneck Dress would be among the beer-esque items for sale.

Hey, that dress would look great with the beer-esque metal Prague chair and the bistro table, so you can’t blame me for trying.

I bought their Italian Riviera dress as a result of their Mother’s Day email last May (a present for myself, cough, cough). The percentage used in the subject line for that email was 20 percent. By the way, I’m wearing that dress in the photo over there in the right sidebar.

Each catalog always has a few dresses that I like so I always, always, pay careful attention to their emails to see if one of my favorite dresses (or the Mrs. Peel leather jacket) are on sale.

It doesn’t matter what their subject line is, I always open their emails, which, as a marketer, is exactly what you want your customers to do.

VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
Share

My pick for the best subject line of the week (using my own delightfully subjective criteria, of course, and limited to those that surfaced in my inbox) is Ryan Healy’s “Can’t sell your house? Stop making payments.” Not the most cheerful of topics, of course, but I opened that one right away out of curiosity and clicked on over to the blog post.

Next up is “Emergency Fix for a Clogged Toilet” from Boardroom’s Bottom Line Secrets newsletter. What a practical subject line. I didn’t have a clogged toilet handy at that moment but I was curious enough to read the email immediately. Plus, I was wondering if they were really going to give the answer to that question or just tease the reader, as they are famous for doing in their newsletters. But they did answer it and now I almost want a toilet to become clogged so I can try it.

Mike Geary from Truth About Abs sent out an email with this subject line: “article marketing disaster — don’t use this company.” Notice how there are no capital letters (not even at the beginning) and the subject line is rather long. I couldn’t help but read that article right away even though I don’t use a company for article marketing. A side note: I notice that Mike doesn’t send out emails that are 50-65 characters in width, like most marketers. He’s OK with long sentences. I’ve long wondered if he’s tested this. I also can’t help but note that those in the fitness niche tend to be the best at sending out interesting emails on a regular basis.

Sean D’Souza of Psychotactics used this subject line: “Why we struggle with our writing.” I liked that one. It isn’t dramatic and isn’t heavy on the curiosity but it uses empathy (“we”) and I liked that it wasn’t focused just on copywriting but on writing in general, so I opened the email.

And, finally, this one from Perry Marshall: “the odd characteristic that most marketing geniuses share.” Again note the absence of capital letters in a long subject line. I think longer subject lines are easier to read when only the first letter is capitalized (or there is no capitalization at all). I usually only ever capitalize every word when the subject line is very short.

Feel free to share your own favorite subject lines in the comments.

VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
Share

My favorite subject line of this past week was Clayton Makepeace’s “The Spanking of a Lifetime.

Plus I liked the content that went with it. Copywriters should read his post about how he lost a recent split test.

I was also very interested to note that he usually only has one day to write a sales letter! Of course he makes a ton of money from these clients, but still, 24 hours to write a 14-24 page financial sales letter is amazing. I hope my clients don’t start getting any ideas!

The other subject line I liked was Matt Furey’s “Massage Your Organ.” I assumed it was going to talk about how the bodyweight exercises he recommends also massage your inner organs. But it was about how in China there are people who will give you massages that specifically massage your organs to remove any, um, blockages, and they’ve done this for thousands of years. Sounds better than a colon cleanse anyway.

Finally, I also liked Ben Settle’sWhy I “Pee” On My Sales Letters.” Don’t worry, PEE is his acronym for “persuade,” “engage” and “entertain.”

Now that I’ve written a few of these email subject line of the week posts I’m starting to wonder…is it possible to use subtlety instead of shock value or entertainment in a subject line and still get a good open rate? I’d like to see more subtlety in my inbox. I use it a lot in my subject lines for clients’ email copy. I might have to post some of them here.

As always, feel free to leave a comment with your own favorite email subject line.

VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.11_1134]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
Share
  

This blog copyright © Anita Ashland: Autoresponder Copywriter

Powered by Flexibility Theme for WordPress

Switch to our mobile site